Extra-curricular tuition has always been a hot-button topic in Singapore because of our competitive meritocratic system.
In the hopes of giving their children an edge, 7 in 10 parents enroll their children in tuition classes, giving rise to an industry that is worth more than $1 billion a year.
But how do those who have to go through the rigors of tuition feel about it? Do our students want it badly? Can they cope without it?
The UrbanWire asked 4 Singaporean students whether they think tuition is a must-have or good-to-have. They also share whether access to tuition can lead to a further class divide in Singapore.
Aung Myin Oo, 19
Amount spent on tuition: $800 – $1,000/ month
When Aung, 19, first came to Singapore from Myanmar at 8, tuition was his “lifeline”.
He found it “hard to catch up” and tuition was a “necessity”, especially when he was in primary school.
Aung also feels that tuition helped him “set aside time where he could focus his mind on academic matters”.
Despite benefitting from tuition, he doesn’t feel like it gives him a leg up over his peers.
“I have friends who don’t have tuition at all, but they’re straight-A students.”
He also feels that tuition isn’t to blame for our social divide but instead “it’s apathy and a lack of social interaction amongst different classes”.
Ivana Faith Ding, 19
Amount spent on tuition: $2,000 – $3000/ month
Ivana Faith Ding, 19, hated her tuition as it was “repetitive and boring”.
But, it was still a “necessity because (she) was from an elite school” and it was “the only way” for her to “keep up with her peers”.
However, she believes that tuition has perpetuated Singapore’s social divide.
“In tuition centers, you (often) only see students from elite schools. Other times, tuition costs so much (that) only the well-off can afford (it). It creates a divide (as) those who truly need tuition can’t afford it and end up lagging behind.”
She witnessed this divide in person while working with underprivileged kids as part of the Social Leadership Challenge.
“From a young age, they already can’t afford preschool. (They) go to primary school… and end up lagging behind. These are the kids who need tuition the most but can’t afford it.”
Tamana Mulchand, 21
Amount spent on tuition: Tamana received free tuition from her mother and as a result, they saved $400 per month
Tamana Mulchand, 21, was able to get free tuition because her mother was a tuition teacher.
Ms Mulchand confessed that tuition was a “necessity” and gave her an “advantage” because she was “a lazy student and appreciated any additional help (she) could get”.
However, she recognized that not everyone has access to tuition and feels that there’s “a disparity (among students) where richer families can provide tuition for their children and some families can’t.”
Despite believing that tuition gave her an advantage, she feels that the education system is “fair” as “there are awards that recognize progress and leadership, giving everyone an avenue to shine”.
Muhammad Tanveer Ejaaz, 15
Amount spent on tuition per month: $0
Tanveer, 15, who grew up in a single-parent household, has never had tuition.
He shared that his “family couldn’t afford tuition, so (he) learned to live without it.”
Tanveer also confessed to being at a disadvantage as he feels that he has to “work harder than (his) friends with tuition” as they have “a teacher who works (on specific areas) that they’re weaker in”.
However, he thinks that tuition could be a double-edged sword as his friends with tuition “don’t listen in class”.